Mad Mab wrote:
Oh I know that, but nonetheless, his original post was 'authencity'. Possibly he corrected it before John managed to quote it but it was
It was, it was, it was, so
Guthrie posted at 1:32 pm.
You are correct, if he changed it before the next post, then it wouldn't show he'd edited it.
The next post was Lucy at 2:15 pm.
However, John did not post until 2:23 pm.
Unless it took him more than 8 minutes to read Guthries unchanged post and then to post "Make that un.", then that's not what happened.
That would also assume that nearly three quarters of an hour after he made the original post, Guthrie came back and edited his post, and coincidentally just before Lucy made her post.
And the further the alleged correction was away from Lucy's post the longer John must have taken between seeing the alleged mistake and making his post. It starts to look increasingly like that isn't what happened.